Monday, October 20, 2014

USANA May Have Made Half a Billion Dollars In Sales From Conducting Illegal Multi-Level Marketing In Mainland China

USANA May Have Received at Least $440 million From Illegal Sales in Mainland China Since 2007

It may be that by secretly recruiting hundreds of thousands of Chinese Nationals as USANA distributors, which violates China's direct selling laws and possibly the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA), USANA may have received $440 million from illegal sales in mainland China since 2007. USANA is a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) company that makes most of its revenue from the product purchased by their sales reps also known as distributors. Mainland China has banned MLM, but that has not stopped USANA from recruiting China's citizens. USANA has hidden this information from investors, auditors, and regulators.

USANA is allowed to conduct MLM business in Hong Kong, which has a population of about 7 million. USANA has also purchased a company called Babycare, which has a direct selling license in mainland China through Single-Level Marketing, which means there are no downlines or commissions paid to any upline members. Since 2009 USANA's revenue for Hong Kong began increasing at a very rapid pace, which outpaced any of their other markets. The number of distributors they reported each quarter was such that 1 in every 100 Hong Kong citizens would have to be a USANA distributor, which was absurd since the ratio of USANA distributors in the United States is about 1 in every 3600 people. USANA's sales in Hong Kong peeked to $48.5 million in the fourth quarter of 2012. Since then, there has been a sharp decline in Hong Kong Sales at the same time a sharp increase in Babycare sales. As of last quarter (Q2-2012) USANA made only $15.4 million from Hong Kong. This is a substantial decline in sales, yet USANA has simply brushed it off as an expected decline as members join Babycare in mainland China rather than USANA in Hong Kong.

What's the big secret you may ask? In order to circumvent foreign laws, USANA recruited Chinese Nationals into USANA and had them register using a fake address in Hong Kong ("Room 1906 Kwong Yat House" for example). This way all of the Chinese citizens appear to be residing in Hong Kong when in fact they lived in areas such as Beijing. They did not join to spend $1000 USD (¥ 6100 CNY) on vitamins because they simply wanted the product (otherwise they would have been Preferred Customers), but joined as distributors so they can participate in MLM, which China considers is a pyramid scheme. Many if not most of them joined with a "3-business center" plan, which means they were sold the idea that they can maximize their profits if they start with the ability to create a bigger downline. Again, all of this is outlawed in mainland China, but that didn't stop USANA from swindling about $440 million from China. But remember, according to USANA these Chinese distributors reside in Hong Kong using the same phoney address!

The evidence that Chinese Nationals signed up as USANA distributors in Hong Kong can be found within the genealogy reports from those distributors who are their upline. The following link was a genealogy report from an upper level USANA distributor who had thousands of Chinese Nationals in their downline. USANA has since blocked the link, but here it is for historical record.
http://www.usana.com/DlmXlsServlet.xls?savedReportId=32397555
I have retained a copy of this document however:  www.mlmpyramid.com/USANA_32397555.xls


The Appearance That Babycare Has Been Growing at a Rapid Rate During The Last Several Quarters May Be Nothing More Than The Manipulation of Number.


USANA has claimed Babycare is growing in mainland China. However, it may be nothing more than the transfer of sales from Hong Kong to Mainland China. Sales that were once attributed to USANA's Hong Kong market is now simply being reported in Babycare. USANA's auditor KPMG LLP should investigate the sales that were once reported as Hong Kong and now seem to be reported as Babycare. So the whole notion that USANA is “growing” its Babycare subsidiary may not be true.

On USANA's last quarter's conference call, Dave Wentz was asked where he projects Hong Kong's sales should stabilize (in light of the rapid decline in sales). Dave Wentz responded with the following (my emphasis in bold highlight):
"Well, Hong Kong's a fairly small market, population wise. And so we believe it will be -- I mean, if you were to compare it to other markets at the same population size, we expect it to be more successful than a number of them. But there will be a level that hits it right, that matches the market size and the number of leaders that we have there. But a lot of focus has moved from Hong Kong to China, as we all know, and that's where a much bigger opportunity is." - Seeking Alpha Transcript
It would seem to me that Dave is trying to justify Hong Kong's declining sales and distributor numbers. He should have simply told investors the truth that Hong Kong's numbers have been grossly overstated for the last several years because the sales were actually from mainland China instead of Hong Kong. Now what if we interpolate the sales from 2007 to the last quarter and consider anything above that line to be from mainland China? I choose 2007 because of evidence that shows Chinese Nationals being recruited into USANA since 2007 using a phoney address as seen in the genealogy report I referenced above.

USANA has been telling investors and stock analysts that Babycare has picked up business in China. However, this might not actually be true. I believe USANA is simply transferring the reported sales from one territory to another to make it appear as if business is growing in China. As you can see, Q1-2013 is the start at which Babycare sales started to sky rocket. This may actually simply be the transfer of reported sales from one market to another. Notice that Hong Kong decreases by almost the same amount Babycare China increases.
Many years ago USANA began recruiting Chinese Nationals from mainland China into their multilevel marketing compensation plan in Hong Kong. China's direct selling law forbids multilevel marketing from being conducted. So what USANA did is have those from China's mainland sign up using a phoney residential address in Hong Kong.

It's one thing if a few rogue USANA associates were breaking the law by signing up people from mainland China. It's another thing for USANA to knowingly circumvent China's laws and have them all share the same phoney address in Hong Kong when they sign up. This may be a violation of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The extent of this violation isn't about a couple dollars from a few bad associates. In fact, it may be closer to $440 Million over the last 6 years that actually is the direct result of Chinese Nationals in mainland China who were illegally participating and conducting a multilevel marketing scheme within their country.

USANA has in the past stated that an undisclosed amount of people from mainland China are purchasing product from Hong Kong for their own personal use and not building a USANA business. Then over the last year, USANA has stated that they have a new policy that restricts people from purchasing USANA product from outside their own market. So those from mainland China are not suppose to purchase USANA product from Hong Kong anymore. USANA has also stated that they are shifting their focus from Hong Kong to Babycare in China. They also admitted that some of those who were signed up in Hong Kong will now be signed up in Babycare in China.


Why Did So Many of USANA's Hong Kong Full-Time Leaders Vanish?

USANA distributors who are able to obtain at least 10,000 sales volume FROM their downline (5000 points on their left leg and 5000 on their right leg) each week for 4 consecutive weeks are given titles such as Gold Director, Ruby Director, Emerald Director, Diamond Director, and Star-Diamond Director. USANA labels this class of distributors as “FULL-TIME DISTRIBUTORS”. Anyone beneath this ranking USANA classifies as only “PART-TIME DISTRIBUTORS”.

Reading USANA's recruiting material one may believe there are a lot of distributors with these high rankings. Those that reach this level can be making $50,000 in commission to over $1 million in commission per year. USANA has had over 2,000,000 distributors since they began in 1992. Over the last several years I have collected data of USANA distributor leadership rankings. As of June 2014 there are only about 3141 USANA distributors in the world that are a rank of Gold Director or higher (full-time), which is an unknown fact that is not disclosed to investors or even new distributors before or after they sign up. Interestingly, over the last two year 531 FULL-TIME USANA distributors have dropped out or have been terminated. Remember, these are distributors who are highly ranked, collecting thousands if not millions in commissions from USANA (approximately $38 million each year according to 2006 US Associate Earnings Documents).
The bigger eye opener is that out of the 531 Full-Time distributors that have left, 378 of them are from Hong Kong alone! 12 Diamond, 7 Emerald, 59 Ruby, and 300 Gold Directors have been removed from Hong Kong and possibly transferred to Babycare. If these members were making the kind of commissions their USANA rank suggests, and they were kicked out of USANA and turned into Babycare Distributors, what incentive would keep them as Babycare distributors if they are all of the sudden going to be collecting no commission at all? Remember, Babycare distributors cannot make a commission from other participants purchases because they cannot have a downline. Yet, Babycare sales and associates have been skyrocketing along with the fact the percent of distributor incentives to net sales did not dramatically change from the loss of all these high ranking USANA distributors that USANA would no longer supposedly be paying commissions to.


Where Are The Regulators?
So what's going on here? I believe USANA auditors need to investigate this issue and get to the bottom of it. I believe the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) needs to also open an investigation into the “PAYMENT FOR REFERRAL” plan USANA has implemented world wide which pays a referral commission to anyone who recruits Chinese Nationals into Babycare and receives commissions from their purchases, even though Babycare distributors are forbidden to participate in MLM. I also believe the SEC needs to open an investigation into USANA's possible violation of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act by circumventing China's laws by having thousands their citizens sign up using a phoney address to participate in USANA's Multilevel Marketing scheme which may be responsible for over $440 million dollars in funds from the citizens in mainland China.

18 comments:

  1. Your argument makes too much sense. Just don't know why after all these years, and after all the compelling evidence on their illegal business practices in China, no regulatory body/agency is doing anything about it yet?

    To further demonstrate your point about the Chinese distributors, all one needs to do is look at any if the recent top income earners, top growth, top distributors signing up most new associates, and preferred customers, and over 90% of these top distributors are Chinese.

    This is nothing new, it has been the trend since 2007. If one ever goes to their international convention, the majority of people rank advancing in stage are Chinese. Coincidence? I think not.

    Hope one day Dave and Myron Wentz get held accountable abd have to give back to the thousands of distributors who fell victim to their scheme.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Greed is the source of energy that makes people believe in it. They believe in instant money because it is just too good to be true.

    It's like all other MLM companies in US. Do you know why there are hundreds of them in US? Why are there so many poor people in US? This is because they are not successful, not knowledgeable and never commit to do any good thing in their lives. Suddenly, there is something called USANA, which can improve health, wealth and donate money to the African (in picture).

    Boom! Usana booklets are the new bible; Usana pills are the magic beams; Usana meetings are the new churches.

    China and another Western country, called New Zealand, knew that MLM is bad but it's hard to stop because people subconsciously knew it was wrong but this was different because it was too good to be true.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ex-USANA Network Marketers should go tell the world how that company is trying to poison and ruin every people's mindset on earning money. They're earning through some other people's payment. How bad is that?! >.<

    ReplyDelete
  4. Haven't you been following NuSkin and Herbalife? China doesn't care about this and their system of laws is enforced differently than in the west. NuSkin was found guilt of conducting illegal mlm meetings about a year ago and China only fined them 500k.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are correct about Nuskin. However, the major difference here is that they had no proof that masses of Chinese Nationals had actually joined and were being paid commissions from downline purchases as is done with MLM. USANA on the other hand went above and beyond by having Chinese Nationals actually join and use a fake address outside mainland China to circumvent the laws. These were hundreds of thousands of active USANA members participating in the MLM structure.

      I believe Chinese officials are simply being paid off to look the other way. But I have no proof of that...

      Delete
  5. I have a friend who's been doing the network marketing thing with USANA. I always tell her that I don't want to join her in that kind of "business". One day, she got pissed about me hating her "business"... And so she blocked me on Facebook. USANA RUINS FRIENDSHIP!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Any friend who is pissed off about you because of usana is an idiot and doesn't not deserve to be your friend. They only want your money.

      It's like will any friend who is pissed off about you because they hate the company you are working for?

      Delete
  6. Hi USANA Watchdog! Can you do some research on USANA in the Philippines? They're everywhere in that country. They annoy a lot of Filipino

    ReplyDelete
  7. It is that time of year again. Usanas annual price increase. Every year the cost of ingredients miraculously increases, every year! Same ingredients that were used yesterday all of a sudden more expensive next day. The cost to consumer never goes down, and Usana NEVER has sale so consumers can save some money. EVER! This company just takes and takes and takes.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi! I came across this page when I searched for information about USANA which is a perfect time. I am doing the research because a American Chinese is persuading me join the business. I am a Chinese citizen, who works in U.S. I agree that China has a big market for supplements, because the food safety, air pollution, and medical quality make people become very aware of their health. Almost everyone trust supplements from U.S., and they believe those can help them to prevent certain disease. American Chinese has the privilege of selling Usana's products to their relatives and friends who still live in China, since they will ask them to buy health supplements in U.S. any way, there is no much difference of purchasing a different brand (either GNC or Usana). I actually did notice that Usana became popular in China, I have met a few people who use it, one of them even said, "now rich people in Beijing all take it." I am very confused now after taking in all the controversial opinion. The Chinese American distributor told me that, "Usana is the best product in the health supplement market.", but she didn't give me much evidence except of showing me a rank and telling me , which I doubt the authenticity athletes use this product. When I searched the their products on Amazon, I didn't see a lot reviews, but most of them are extremely positive. That also makes me wonder the safety of taking the product, like, how can something make all these miraculous effect in a few days. I am hesitate on joining them now. It seems that it doesn't hurt to join, because I don't need to pay a lot, and I am positive people will buy the products from me, because they ask me to buy those things anyway. But I am worried at the same time, my instinct told me some parts of it is just not right, which I can't tell... I would like to hear more opinion from anyone... Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Came Across

    The many things that you will hurt you join. You will hurt your reputation, Usana is not about the product, it is about singing up more people. The biggest winners will be the persons who recruited you. The losers will be the people you try to recruit.
    The products are overpriced and you will be out $1200. If you want to believe what Usana tells the recruits, then you will have also lost your mind.
    Usana products do not cure anything. Read the label on the products.

    Do you know who was put in your up-line today?




    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. $1200 is nothing to that chinese guy dude.

      that the cost of iphone 6 gold if you didn't notice and peopl snatch it up like it's a loaf of bread.

      product doesn't cure anything, but can maintain a healthy life style and preventive measure. Anyone that say it cure doesn't know wt-f they are talking about.

      btw, it's not about 'singing up more people'.. who the heck wants to sing it up.. it's not american idol. It's signing up more people. =p

      Delete
  10. Kim-il-dinh is in China brainwashing Chinese people. take down the brainwashers and you take down the fake dreams.

    ReplyDelete
  11. what will i do???!! please answer me.. i have a friend and hes recruiting me.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dan

    Your friend is not your friend. Get a new friend.

    ReplyDelete
  13. So wathever happend to the post I posted in the past.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't post anything that contains inappropriate language. I don't know what you posted. Did it show up on the forum at some time? I get thousands of postings that end up automatically in the spam box, which I don't bother checking. Feel free to repost whatever it was. Sorry it's not here. Also, have you checked the other articles? Maybe you posted there. If there are too many comments on a particular article, you have to click "load more" at the bottom of the page (it's dumb, but it is blogger.com and out of my control) to view more comments.

      Delete
  14. What ? Chinese officials paid to look the other way .that never happens. Its probably all just a coincidence its gone on so long

    ReplyDelete

Inappropriate language may cause comment not to be added. Please refrain from using bad language. If your posting does not show up after a day, please email me with your comment so I can search for it in the spam box. Thank you.
usanawatchdog@gmail.com